cá cược bóng đá_các trò chơi cờ bạc_m88 mobile

McGill-Queen's UP - April 21, 2009 - 10 Comments

The Ishtar Gate

The Ishtar Gate by Diana Brebner

Reviewed by Jenna Butler

“There is no turning back from fear, or joy,” Diana Brebner writes, and this line hints at the vast, and at times brutal, scope of the work contained in her final (posthumous) collection The Ishtar Gate.

Brebner is not an easy poet to read. Picked out in goddesses and angels, often taut and serious in tone, her poems nonetheless strike left of centre with surprising power. As Stephanie Bolster points out in the foreword to Brebner’s final collection, “There was no mediation between poem and audience, no apology. Take it or leave it, she seemed to say. If you find this too sentimental, too elemental, that’s fine; there are other poets to come.”

Much of the ambivalence surrounding Brebner’s poetry stems from the tension in her work, its driving power of abstraction. Perhaps, though, it is this reliance upon abstraction, the refusal by the poet to give the audience the relief of concrete references, that winds her poems up in such twists of brilliance. The very fact that the poems are sometimes stilted and a little clumsy in structure forces the reader’s awareness of what the poem is saying, rather than being caught up in how it is doing so. As for the constant critique that Brebner seems to think too much and feel too little in her work, she responds wryly:

I have not shed tears onto

your pages perhaps it is only
because I would not hurt you

with your indifference.
(“For the Poet Who Told Me to Think Less and Feel More” 116)

The element of the Ishtar Gate itself is noteworthy because of the connections one may read between the symbolism of the gate and Brebner’s work. The Ishtar Gate, unearthed by Koldewey in 1920, dates from the reign of King Nebuchadnezzar. Originally one of the eight entrances to Babylon, the gate is now housed in a museum in Berlin. To Brebner, the gate represents the merging of the ancient goddess-based cultures of the East with the more rational, scientific thought of the West. Interestingly enough, of the three figures depicted on the gate (the lion, the aurochs and the sirrush), the figure of the sirrush has incited great curiosity. Much of Babylonian sculpture at the time focused on animals that were contemporary to the age; the sirrush, however, is a dragon, a figure of myth.

It seems appropriate, then, for Brebner to have selected such a title, with all its implied hints of mystery and displacement, as she faced much the same situation in regard to criticism of her work. As Bolster states in the introduction to The Ishtar Gate:

Her predilection for traditional verse forms, deemed retrograde by many Canadian poets during the 80s and 90s, heightened her isolation. Yet her perverse playfulness was such that one wonders if she chose this path in protest – the “traditional” as a daring opposition to the norm of free verse – and to ensure the marginality that granted her independence and privacy. (xii)

The beauty in this poetry – and there is a great deal of beauty resident in Brebner’s work – is in her heightened awareness of the inner world. The outer world, more immediate and concrete, is not always trustworthy, and so the inner world gains a terse and brilliant depth in the outer world’s absence:

But the world in air is
a perplexing place. Nostalgia displaces memory,

and only the dead, or the brave, risk the
dark place beneath their necks, the shadow

that opens, and reveals black, guttered
(“Salmon on Saran” 55)

Brebner is a woman unafraid to confront pain and what it means. She speaks of death, abuse, and loss with equanimity, acknowledging their power, and yet refusing to allow them autonomous voice:

Spider: small, hopping, dancing girl.
When did you learn how to walk on water?

She makes her way across: webs, small feats, whirl
on the cosmos. Contentment. Calm. What are

we moving towards? The spider crosses
water, takes her chances, bears her losses.
(“The Spider” 29)

Her poetry sings with what has been broken; she deals with the intrusive nature of memory with a measured hand, and in doing so creates moments that are startling in their poignancy:

Some things will not

forget how they came up from emptiness:
bluebells (called weed and torn up), lily-
of-the-valley (between concrete wall
and asphalt plane) green asymptotes
never quite giving up the ghost, never

blue morning glory on the Frost fence
and Siberian irises up against invisible
walls, and old lilac invading the thick
black lie which says: death, which
says, nothing is perfect, or even close.
(“The Perfect Garden” 51)

There is no respite from the ugly in this book, although violent events and memories are presented in such a calm manner that their very restraint is disturbing. There is no mediation for the reader, no attempt to airbrush. After all, as Brebner claims, “Protection / is not what we need, but the recognition / that we are all beautiful beyond injury” (“Restoration” 47).

Ultimately, in defiance of the criticism Brebner’s work seems inevitably to draw, this is a lush collection in spite of its conscious restraint. The Ishtar Gate reveals that beauty can indeed be found in the general, in that which refuses to be pinned down by a word:

Among the lilies you hack
from their moorings is one thing, a splendour

that is nameless, white, yellow flower, now
the water, stars exploding at the bow.
(“Open Among the Lilies” 25)

Jenna Butler is an educator and poet who makes her home in Edmonton. Her work has garnered a number of awards, including CBC’s Alberta Anthology, and has been widely published in journals, anthologies and literary magazines in Canada and abroad. She is the founding editor of Rubicon Press.


On July 05, 2012, Poland Stamps said:

You are correct when you mention that Brebner is not an easy poet to read. But her poems are indeed very powerful. poland stamps

On July 13, 2012, Lisa Maxin said:

The Ishtar Gate by Diana Brebner is a lovely and interesting book. I like this book functionally enjoyable for the simply excellent writing style. Can you please post Irvine therapist book for the next entry? Thanks! smile

On February 20, 2013, David Grant said:

@Lisa, I found this very interesting also. As the reviewer says, it’s not “easy” reading. I definitely needed a quite room and no outside distractions. - David G. (webmaster @ Vancouver bloggers website)

Add a Comment



Remember my personal information.
Notify me of follow-up comments?

We don't know if you're a human. Confirm below:

Jack and Jill went up the...? (4 character(s) required)

  • it’s really great that your website has so much interesting stuff to read. Come visit mine: flexa plus
    said TomD on May 02, 2016
    about The Crisp Day Closing on My Hand: The Poetry of M. Travis Lane edited by Jeanette Lynes
  • It’s a nice and very informative website and post too.You can benefited all others cosmetica industries as well. cosmetica groothandel …
    said acosmetica groothandel on January 02, 2016
    about Pendas Productions
  • Very very thanks for like this poetry.I am proud after looked on poetry.Ian LeTourneau’s reviewed poetry have given me many many …
    said cosmetica groothandel on December 30, 2015
    about The Crisp Day Closing on My Hand: The Poetry of M. Travis Lane edited by Jeanette Lynes
  • Wow it’s a hots poetry.So I lov,like this poetry.My need knowledge,which I have taken from The Mechanical Bird, Asa Boxer’s. cosmetica …
    said cosmetica groothandel on December 30, 2015
    about The Mechanical Bird by Asa Boxer
  • Wow what’s a nice poetry.I love like this poetry.I have read it and take some knowledge from Stone Sightings,Madeline Sonik. cosmetica …
    said cosmetica groothandel on December 30, 2015
    about Stone Sightings by Madeline Sonik
  • I am really happy After got this blog.g We seen abriel’s beach by the Neal McLeod. cosmetica groothandel
    said cosmetica groothandel on December 30, 2015
    about Gabriel’s Beach by Neal McLeod
  • I learn a lesson from you that ladies can do all the thing. cosmetica groothandel
    said acosmetica groothandel on December 28, 2015
    about Lady Godiva and Me by Liam Guilar
  • I love to hear always about MJ.In my life I wanted to be like MJ but I did not understand that …
    said Niamal Wakil on December 24, 2015
    about The Meaning of Michael Jackson
  • You made a most important point about poet.Without spectra poet has nothing.You may follow this link cosmetica grothandel for any cosmetic. …
    said Niamal Wakil on December 20, 2015
    about Nerve Language by Brian Henderson
  • After reading post I have read the poem of Gillian Sze.I feel the hit of this poet.It is really awesome that …
    said Niamal Wakil on December 17, 2015
    about Fish Bones by Gillian Sze